Feb 19, 2024 Leave a message

Light Emitting Diodes vs Tungsten Filament Lamps as Light Sources

Two Different Ways of Making Light

Light emitting diodes and tungsten filament lamps both produce light, but the physical processes behind them are entirely different. A light emitting diode is a semiconductor device, built around a junction between p-type and n-type material. When a forward voltage is applied, electrons and holes recombine, and the energy released in that recombination appears as photons. The colour is set by the band gap of the semiconductor, which depends on the material system rather than on any coating or filter.

A tungsten filament lamp is a thermal source. Current is passed through a filament of metallic tungsten, which is heated until it glows. The spectrum is continuous and the light output depends on filament temperature: the higher the temperature, the greater the share of visible radiation and the shorter the service life, because tungsten evaporates from the filament while it is hot.

How the Emitting Material Sets the Colour

Because the wavelength of an LED is fixed by the band gap of its semiconductor, different colours require different materials. Gallium arsenide based structures emit in the red, gallium phosphide in the green, silicon carbide in the yellow, and gallium nitride in the blue and near ultraviolet. White devices are normally built from a blue emitting gallium nitride die combined with a phosphor that converts part of the blue light into longer wavelengths.

The tungsten lamp has no such selectivity. Its output is a continuous spectrum spanning the visible region from about 400 nm to 780 nm, with a large fraction of the total radiation emitted in the infrared. This broad, smooth output is the reason the tungsten lamp became the working visible source in spectrophotometry, where a continuum is needed to scan wavelength by wavelength.

Lifetime, Efficiency and Heat

LED lifetime is limited mainly by the quality of the semiconductor chip and by optical and thermal degradation of the package, not by consumption of the emitting material.

Tungsten filament lifetime is limited by evaporation and thinning of the filament, so it depends directly on the quality of the tungsten wire and on the operating temperature.

LEDs convert a much larger share of the input energy into visible light and reject comparatively little heat by radiation, although heat must still be conducted away from the junction to preserve life.

Incandescent lamps radiate most of their energy as heat, so visible output is only a small fraction of the input power and the filament is at once the light source and the weak point.

Light Sources in Measurement Instruments

For visible range spectrophotometry the tungsten filament lamp remains a practical source, because it provides a stable continuous spectrum across the whole visible band. Its useful output extends beyond the visible into the near infrared, reaching wavelengths of the order of 3 micrometres, which makes it suitable as a near infrared source as well. In such instruments the lamp is run from a stabilised supply, and the smooth continuum allows the monochromator to select any narrow band of interest.

LEDs are used differently in instruments. They are common as indicator lamps on panels and in circuits, and arrays of them are used in displays and in dedicated photometers where a narrow band or a small number of fixed wavelengths is sufficient. Where a full scan is required, the continuous source still has the advantage.

Practical Comparison

Aspect Light emitting diode Tungsten filament lamp
Emission mechanism Electron-hole recombination in a semiconductor junction Thermal radiation from a heated filament
Spectrum Narrow band set by the band gap; phosphor conversion for white light Continuous, about 400-780 nm in the visible region
Life limiting factor Chip quality and package degradation Filament evaporation and thinning
Heat generation Low during emission, but junction cooling is required High; most input power leaves as heat
Typical instrument role Indicators, displays, fixed wavelength photometry Continuous visible and near infrared source

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the essential difference between an LED and a tungsten filament lamp?
An LED produces light when electrons and holes recombine in a semiconductor junction, while a tungsten filament lamp produces light by heating a metal filament until it glows.

Q: Why do LEDs last longer?
Because the emitting process does not consume the emitting material and releases little heat at the junction, the light output is not limited by evaporation as it is in a filament.

Q: Why do different coloured LEDs need different materials?
The colour is set by the band gap of the semiconductor, so red, green, yellow and blue devices are made from different compound systems.

Q: Why is a tungsten lamp used in a spectrophotometer?
It gives a continuous spectrum across the visible range and into the near infrared, which allows the instrument to scan any selected wavelength.

Q: Is the tungsten filament lamp obsolete?
No. Although it has been displaced from general lighting by more efficient lamps, it still holds a large share of the market and remains popular where its simple form and its continuous spectrum are useful.

Q: What limits the life of a tungsten filament?
The filament evaporates and thins while it is hot, so life depends on the operating temperature and on the quality of the tungsten wire.

Send Inquiry

Home

Phone

E-mail

Inquiry